#7670: "The ability to copy a single black worker and get the extra black rail advancement didn't work when "
Hva handler denne rapporten om?
Hva har skjedd, eller hva gjelder det? Vennligst velg
Hva har skjedd, eller hva gjelder det? Vennligst velg
Vennligst sjekk om det allerede er en rapport om samme emne
Hvis ja, vennligst STEM på denne rapporten. Rapporter med flest stemmer er gitt PRIORITET!
# | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
---|
Detaljert beskrivelse
• Vennligst kopier/lim inn feilmeldingen du ser på skjermen, om mulig.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Vennligst forklar hva du ønsket å gjøre, samt hva du faktisk gjorde og hva som skjedde
93• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Vennligst kopier / lim inn teksten som vises på engelsk i stedet for språket ditt. Hvis du har et skjermbilde av denne feilen (alltid lurt) kan du bruke Imgur.com for å laste det opp og kopiere inn lenken til bildet her.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Er denne teksten tilgjengelig i translation system? Hvis ja, har den blitt oversatt i mer enn 24 timer?
93• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Vennligst forklar ditt forslag nøyaktig og konsistent slik at det er så enkelt som mulig å forstå hva du mener.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Hva ble vist på skjermen når du ble blokkert (Tom skjerm? Del av spillgrensesnittet? Feilmelding?)
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Hvilken del av reglene ble ikke respektert av BGA-tilpasningen
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Er regelbruddet tydelig i spilloggen? Hvis ja, Hvilket trekknummer?
93• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Hva var spillhandlingen du ønsket å gjøre?
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hva prøvde du å gjøre for å trigge denne spillhandlingen?
93• Hva skjer når du prøver å gjøre dette (feilmelding, meldingsstatus for meldingsfelt, ...)?
• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• På hvilket tidspunkt i spillet oppsto problemet (hva var den daværende spillinstruksjonen)?
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hva skjer når du forsøker å gjøre en spillhandling (feilmelding, spillstatusfeltmelding, ...)?
93• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Vennligst beskriv visningsproblemet. Hvis du har et skjermbilde av denne feilen (alltid lurt) kan du bruke Imgur.com for å laste det opp og kopiere inn lenken til bildet her.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Vennligst kopier / lim inn teksten som vises på engelsk i stedet for språket ditt. Hvis du har et skjermbilde av denne feilen (alltid lurt) kan du bruke Imgur.com for å laste det opp og kopiere inn lenken til bildet her.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Er denne teksten tilgjengelig i translation system? Hvis ja, har den blitt oversatt i mer enn 24 timer?
93• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
• Vennligst forklar ditt forslag nøyaktig og konsistent slik at det er så enkelt som mulig å forstå hva du mener.
1. Reuse of a black worker should still give +1 black advancement.
2. The action should be used in its entirety, unless it is an owned engineer. But the engine allows to skip an action.• Hvilken nettleser bruker du?
Mozilla v52.1.2 ESR x64
Rapporthistorikk
- Used engineer #10 (1 industry + 1 black advancement)
- Reached factory #3 (reuse action)
- Selected two black advancements, activated by the black worker.
- Only had option to do 2 black advancements, while according to rules I should have 3.
- After finishing the turn, the log displays that the black track advancement is skipped, while according to rules the action must be used in its entirety, with the only exception of owned engineers (this is the second bug).
if you use black worker on double black action if you used up 2 black, the 3rd one that comes from black
worker can be skipped, it also applies to factories and advantage token actions.
There is still a bug I guess that duplication did not happen, I really hoped it was fixed
if you use black worker on double black action if you used up 2 black, the 3rd one that comes from black
worker can be skipped, it also applies to factories and advantage token actions.
Even if it sounds reasonable, is there official statement in rules/FAQ/errata?
Moved my black token onto engineer #14 and took 3 movements including bonus for 5 industry movements that includes passing a doubler industry. I selecetd to double my black token on Engineer #14 space and only got 2 movements .
boardgamearena.com/1/russianrailroads?table=94805841
I used factory 3 to reuse the "2 black track advances" space. I had used that space with my black worker, but I did not get the extra advance.
In my case, this all happened on the same turn. I placed the black worker in that space, advanced 3 black tracks, and that triggered me getting an advantage. I chose the advantage that allowed me to advance on the industry track, which let me advance onto factory 3.
So I wonder if the issue is when you are getting two (or more, potentially) black worker bonus advances on the same turn. If you're internally keeping some flag to check that the bonus has already been taken that turn, maybe that could be the issue?
In this game, I ended up cancelling my move and doing something else, because I only wanted to reuse that space if I got the extra advancement on the track. (In case you wanted to look at the game logs)
1. If the action with the black worker was performed IN THE SAME TURN (examples given by LuckyYou, SuicideKing and mitcharf) as the repetition of that action, the position of the black worker has not yet been updated and the extra advancement is therefore not added, because it is assumed that the black worker is in a different position.
2. If you repeat a black worker's action TWICE or more often (if theoretically possible) in the same turn you get only ONE extra black track advancement even if the conditions were fulfilled more often (Mitcharf's guess was right, that there is just a flag whether the bonus was already taken and not a counter for potentially multiple bonuses in a single turn).
Additionally, it is even possible to get the extra advancement if you did not fulfill the requirements:
=> If the black worker is placed on an action space that allows any advancement (e.g. Engineer 5) and you repeat that action, you will get the extra black track advancement even if you perform a black advancement from another action and advance e.g. your grey or brown track with the engineer action (where the black worker was placed) that was repeated. But according to the rules, you must perform a black track advancement with the action the black worker executed. At the moment it is just checked if a black track is advanced at all.
Example: The black worker was placed on Engineer 5 in your last turn. This turn you place another worker on Engineer 10 (Industry and Black Track Advancement). First, you move your industry marker on factory #3, and repeat the black worker action from your previous turn. Now, you advance your black track (second action of Engineer 5) and already get the extra advancement. Now you can move any other track with the repeated black worker action because you already got your extra advantage. The same applies if the black worker was placed on an action space that even theoretically cannot advance black tracks (e.g. 2 roubles or industry advancement). Both cases should NOT unlock the extra black track advancement according to the rules.
Same situation, black worker repeated in the same turn it was placed. The log even says "skipped Black Track Advancement" while the game said "Move Not Authorized Now" when I tried using the final black rail move
Table #132801886
Move #36
Please note that all moves occurred on the SAME turn; this may be relevant to the bug.
boardgamearena.com/table?table=167688312
Move 88: Using black worker on Engineer #10.
-> Received 1x Industry advancement and 2x Black Rail advancements.
-> Activated factory #3.
-> Copied Black Worker on Engineer #10.
-> Received 1x Industry advancement and only 1x Black Rail advancements, instead of 2x advancements.
Please note below: "Skipped a black rail advancement"
I wasn't able to perform it at all.
Move 88:
Wireshark placed [meeple_10_000000] onto "Engineer 10: Industry Advancement and Black Track Advancement" action space
Wireshark moved [industrymarker_2_008000] into [industry_slot_x_7_008000]
Wireshark moved [rail_black_1_008000] into [railslot_slot_1_8_008000]
Wireshark moved [rail_black_1_008000] into [railslot_slot_1_9_008000]
Wireshark moved [industrymarker_1_008000] into [industry_slot_x_15_008000]
Wireshark moved [rail_black_1_008000] into [railslot_slot_1_10_008000]
Wireshark unlocked natural tracks
Wireshark gained [rail_beige_1_008000]
Wireshark gained [rail_beige_2_008000]
Wireshark skipped Black Track Advancement
Table #190598398
Move 149
Same story again: I put the black worker on Engineer #10, and moved the industry marker on factory #3 to immediately repeat the action on Engineer #10 again in the same turn. After not being allowed to advance on the black track for the fourth time, "I skipped the Black Track Advancement."
As during my move I also earned two advancements, I once did an undo before confirming my move, to try the same in a different order. But that didn't fix the bug either.
"Special case: If you choose a space with the wood-colored worker on it, you do not receive a second additional step."
The wood-colored worker take place of the black worker of the original Russian Railroads, so in the absense of the specification in the origianl version can this special case be applied even to the black worker and with that not provide the extra move repeated? I think so.
Page 48 of the official Ulimate railroads rulebook:
images.zmangames.com/filer_public/82/04/82048553-8cfe-49aa-9c39-6140da56f00f/ultimate_railroads_rulebook-v2_en.pdf
Table #229378131
Move #71
Progression 29%
Didn't occur when I used "one Black or Grey track advancement space". Instead of using the black worker, the game used my gold coin that I was wanting to hold on to. The game did not give me the option to use the black worker.
I use my worker to advance on St. Pete getting the ? for 5 industry steps. Moving over factory 3 gives me only one black step copying engineer 3. According to the official rules (faq) I should get two, see www.hans-im-glueck.de/_Resources/Persistent/8fd5118ab6c9220ea0e9bcd96910ea50f893c358/faq_mitErweiterungen_v3.pdf
Since this is an Arena game - What happens to such games with a bug? Do we have to finish the game regardless of the bug or is there a way to stop and cancel the game?
Table #373707845
I'm on mobile, so I cannot find the move number, but it was my second to last turn of the game.
The log says that I skipped the extra advancment, but I was not allowed to make it.
Legg til noe i denne rapporten
- En annen bord ID / flytt ID
- Løste F5 problemet?
- Oppstod problemet gjentatte ganger? Hver gang? Tilfeldig?
- Hvis du har et skjermbilde av denne feilen (alltid lurt) kan du bruke Imgur.com for å laste det opp og kopiere inn lenken til bildet her.